Games like Arithmancy, ranked by tags and themes. Prices included.

1
Cryptic Escape
100%positive
PLN 22.99
2
The Alchemist's Apprentice in the Maze of Madness
PLN 24.04
3
Arx Fatalis
88%positive
PLN 5.59
4
ByteRogue
100%positive
PLN 11.51
5
Rune Ark
61%positive
PLN 7.42
6
Cryptmaster
93%positive
PLN 2.48
7
Crypt of the Serpent King
83%positive
PLN 8.99
8
Clockfall
96%positive
PLN 8.71
9
Dungeon Tracer
75%positive
PLN 4.15
10
Hyper Dungeon Crawler
75%positive
PLN 19.19
11
Devious Dungeon
82%positive
PLN 17.74
12
Unwanted Dungeon
93%positive
PLN 14.99
13
CRYPTARK
82%positive
PLN 2.63
14
Scholar of the Arcane Arts
86%positive
PLN 6.18
15
369
80%positive
PLN 21.99
16
Relic of The Dungeon
50%positive
PLN 8.99
17
Arcane Tower Survivors
77%positive
PLN 17.99
18
The Dungeon-Dungeon Awaits
100%positive
PLN 22.99
19
Number Dungeon
94%positive
PLN 9.44
20
The Dark Cave
82%positive
PLN 22.99
21
Mage
82%positive
PLN 6.40
22
Amulet
65%positive
PLN 22.99
23
Dungeons & Darkness
69%positive
PLN 7.19
What games are like Arithmancy?

The closest matches to Arithmancy right now are Path of Achra, Collateral Dungeon, Adventurer's Gambit: Dungeons of Fortune, Cryptic Escape, Alchemic Dungeons DX. The ranking compares 49 games by shared tags, theme and review quality, each with its cheapest price across official stores and keyshops.