Games like Holy Crap, ranked by tags and themes. Prices included.

1
Imaginary Friend Asylum
100%positive
PLN 22.99
2
WTF Is Wrong With You?
93%positive
PLN 8.99
3
The Confession
95%positive
PLN 8.99
4
Naked News
65%positive
PLN 4.49
5
GAG
75%positive
PLN 8.99
6
Cruelty Squad
96%positive
PLN 71.99
7
The Divine Invasion
75%positive
PLN 5.27
8
God For A Day
57%positive
PLN 38.00
9
Outsanity
71%positive
PLN 27.50
10
Antihorror
74%positive
PLN 8.99
11
Scarlet Hollow
98%positive
PLN 69.64
12
Critters for Sale
94%positive
PLN 35.99
13
Godly Corp
76%positive
PLN 2.59
14
Fhtagn! - Tales of the Creeping Madness
96%positive
PLN 17.90
15
Horripilant
93%positive
PLN 21.00
16
Foul Bliss
68%positive
PLN 22.99
17
The Horrorscope
94%positive
PLN 8.99
18
Crisol: Theater of Idols
86%positive
PLN 65.99
19
JEF
92%positive
PLN 13.99
20
The Gap
95%positive
PLN 19.99
21
The Test: Reality Check
97%positive
PLN 22.99
22
Crimson Gray
96%positive
PLN 35.99
23
CaseCracker
89%positive
PLN 35.99
24
Holy Shift
81%positive
PLN 8.99
25
The Agony
57%positive
PLN 4.26
26
The Cradle
64%positive
PLN 4.49
27
Great God Grove
99%positive
PLN 91.99
28
Cult Nation
88%positive
PLN 8.72
29
CRUELTY
73%positive
PLN 29.75
30
The Fabulous Fear Machine
90%positive
PLN 59.99
31
Hyperbolica
83%positive
PLN 4.75
32
Sainthood
96%positive
PLN 45.99
33
The Christmas Cackler
98%positive
PLN 11.24
34
NALOGI
78%positive
PLN 3.14
35
GlitchSPANKR
97%positive
PLN 36.49
36
SIMULACRA
90%positive
PLN 3.25
37
Mess Adventures 2
84%positive
PLN 22.99
38
Horror
69%positive
PLN 8.99
What games are like Holy Crap?

The closest matches to Holy Crap right now are Imaginary Friend Asylum, WTF Is Wrong With You?, The Confession, Naked News, GAG. The ranking compares 42 games by shared tags, theme and review quality, each with its cheapest price across official stores and keyshops.