Games like Dumpster Baby, ranked by tags and themes. Prices included.

1
BAD END THEATER
98%positive
PLN 9.29
2
Nocturnals
87%positive
PLN 36.99
3
Growing Up
88%positive
PLN 34.11
4
Adorable Adventures
93%positive
PLN 51.56
5
Little Goody Two Shoes
95%positive
PLN 45.29
6
Social Caterpillar
100%positive
PLN 22.99
7
Dustborn
67%positive
PLN 5.23
8
1 to 1 humanoid edible toys
93%positive
PLN 36.99
9
Small Town Emo
10
Help! I've Been Cursed With a Bubble Butt
100%positive
PLN 13.49
11
Tiny Errands
12
Misc. A Tiny Tale
98%positive
PLN 91.99
13
Baby Steps
90%positive
PLN 38.65
14
Ballshit
96%positive
PLN 12.97
15
Funi Raccoon Game
99%positive
PLN 48.99
16
Tiny Bunny
83%positive
PLN 49.99
17
Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven
95%positive
PLN 22.94
18
Salad Fields
100%positive
PLN 53.99
19
GOOD LUCK BABY!
95%positive
PLN 33.99
20
Bundle of Joy
96%positive
PLN 31.99
21
I Write Games Not Tragedies
100%positive
PLN 59.99
22
Gender Dysphoria
94%positive
PLN 22.96
23
The Parenting Simulator
88%positive
PLN 27.50
24
Diaries of a Spaceport Janitor
73%positive
PLN 2.85
25
Depanneur Nocturne
96%positive
PLN 22.99
26
Dead Pets: A Punk Rock Slice of Life Sim
97%positive
PLN 38.44
27
Poubelle City
100%positive
PLN 17.99
28
Dyscourse
77%positive
PLN 35.06
29
The Cleaner
87%positive
PLN 4.49
30
The Swamp Daughter
31
The Untitled Show
32
La Galerie des Toilettes
95%positive
PLN 55.49
What games are like Dumpster Baby?

The closest matches to Dumpster Baby right now are BAD END THEATER, Nocturnals, Growing Up, Adorable Adventures, Little Goody Two Shoes. The ranking compares 32 games by shared tags, theme and review quality, each with its cheapest price across official stores and keyshops.