Games like Motel Nightmares, ranked by tags and themes. Prices included.

1
Happy Hotel
100%positive
PLN 17.99
2
DREAM LOGIC
90%positive
PLN 10.59
3
Inside the Backrooms
80%positive
PLN 31.99
4
Lair of Torment
71%positive
PLN 9.89
5
Nomad Nightmare - Episode 1: Awakening
64%positive
PLN 13.49
6
No Vacancy Tonight
100%positive
PLN 40.99
7
Insomnis
91%positive
PLN 62.99
8
Horrible Dream
9
Paranormal Torment
81%positive
PLN 6.89
10
Wake Up The House
100%positive
PLN 13.49
11
School of Nightmares
50%positive
PLN 37.99
12
In Nightmare
82%positive
PLN 11.11
13
MIND CORRIDORS: Paroniria
95%positive
PLN 54.99
14
Night Clerk
79%positive
PLN 16.75
15
The Inn-Sanity
96%positive
PLN 36.99
16
Them
90%positive
PLN 12.15
17
Dymension:Scary Horror Survival Shooter
35%positive
PLN 17.99
18
Midnight: Submersion - Nightmare Horror Story
84%positive
PLN 5.71
19
Paragnosia
90%positive
PLN 17.99
20
Traumada
93%positive
PLN 17.99
21
The Guest
74%positive
PLN 35.99
22
The motel
85%positive
PLN 8.99
23
Mechanis Obscura
24
The Exit of Nightmare
67%positive
PLN 27.50
25
Bump in the Night
86%positive
PLN 13.49
26
Home Snatch
79%positive
PLN 17.99
27
Nightmare
33%positive
PLN 13.49
28
Locked In
40%positive
PLN 27.50
29
Horror Maze
73%positive
PLN 10.99
30
Apartment of Death
89%positive
PLN 4.88
31
August Night
72%positive
PLN 2.33
32
In Dark Sleep
60%positive
PLN 22.99
33
The Long Night
34
Terror Mansion
27%positive
PLN 36.99
35
scary hotel
100%positive
PLN 10.99
36
Noctem
71%positive
PLN 27.50
37
City of Nightmares
71%positive
PLN 13.49
38
Nocturia The Game
77%positive
PLN 10.00
39
Trapped: Family Vacation
91%positive
PLN 22.99
40
Inn 8
41
Nightmarise
100%positive
PLN 17.99
42
Backrooms: Realism
PLN 22.99
43
THE ILLUSION: NIGHTMARE
62%positive
PLN 100.00
44
Final Night
0%positive
PLN 31.99
45
Horror
70%positive
PLN 8.99
What games are like Motel Nightmares?

The closest matches to Motel Nightmares right now are Happy Hotel, DREAM LOGIC, Inside the Backrooms, Lair of Torment, Nomad Nightmare - Episode 1: Awakening. The ranking compares 45 games by shared tags, theme and review quality, each with its cheapest price across official stores and keyshops.