Games like Mystery Island:Missing Amy, ranked by tags and themes. Prices included.
1
76Tiny Room Stories: Town Mystery
202187%positive(862)
PLN 35.99PLN 8.99
288The Case of the Golden Idol
202298%positive(10.8K)
PLN 87.49PLN 26.19
358Elegant Sleuth:Mystic Family
2025100%positive(1)
PLN 31.99
450Mystery Island：Enigmatic Painting
202550%positive(4)
PLN 31.99
582The Rise of the Golden Idol
202493%positive(4.1K)
PLN 86.49PLN 43.69
677Intruder In Antiquonia
Trending up
202291%positive(117)
PLN 59.99
782Mind Diver
202596%positive(358)
PLN 77.19PLN 5.09
881Scholar Adventure: Mystery of Silence
202596%positive(100)
PLN 34.48
979Down in Bermuda
202189%positive(1.6K)
PLN 37.38
1057Detective March Forward - The Missing Will
202067%positive(9)
PLN 7.86
1184Meridian 157: Chapter 3
202197%positive(443)
PLN 27.50
1280Unforeseen Incidents
201887%positive(1.1K)
PLN 71.86
13Pixel Detective: Curse of the Paintings
2026
—
1480Meridian 157: Chapter 1
202093%positive(367)
PLN 17.99
1582Nancy Drew®: Danger on Deception Island
Trending up
200992%positive(292)
PLN 45.99
1652Untold Mystery: Angel’s Cry
Trending up
201454%positive(125)
PLN 45.99
1773Amanda the Adventurer 2
202483%positive(1.5K)
PLN 36.35
1884Return to Shironagasu Island
202094%positive(4.2K)
PLN 17.99
1983Meridian 157: Chapter 2
202096%positive(247)
PLN 22.99
2073Bent Oak Island
2024100%positive(18)
PLN 67.99
2168Marcella Moon: Secret on the Hill
Trending up
202089%positive(19)
PLN 17.99
2275Mystery of the Malign
Trending up
202594%positive(82)
PLN 63.99
2382Detective Instinct: Farewell, My Beloved
202594%positive(434)
PLN 71.99PLN 50.39
24Season Island
—
2552Mystery of Camp Enigma 2: Point & Click Puzzle Adventure
202156%positive(9)
PLN 29.75
2673The Wishing Stone
2021100%positive(17)
PLN 32.99
2789Enigma of Fear
202497%positive(10.2K)
PLN 21.17
2850Mystery Of Camp Enigma
202150%positive(14)
PLN 29.75
2984Amanda the Adventurer
202394%positive(7.2K)
PLN 3.25
3066The Samaritan Paradox
Trending up
201472%positive(271)
PLN 5.44
3159The Isle Tide Hotel
202365%positive(275)
PLN 6.87
3268Murder Mystery Mayhem AI
202692%positive(12)
PLN 38.50
3373Dahlia View
202184%positive(370)
PLN 4.75
34The Mystery of Oak Island
2026
—
3565Crime Secrets: Crimson Lily
Trending up
201674%positive(506)
PLN 19.83
3662Sinking Island
201470%positive(279)
PLN 1.48
37MurderAt
—
38Ad Memoriam
—
3979Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden
201490%positive(1.5K)
PLN 14.96
4068Alice Trapped Beyond Wonderland
202184%positive(38)
PLN 17.99
4181Call of the Sea
202088%positive(6.3K)
PLN 10.18
4269Call of the Golden Valley
202586%positive(44)
PLN 91.99
4371Marlon’s Mystery: The darkside of crime
Trending up
202388%positive(74)
PLN 45.99
4466Ashes of Holloway Bay
2026100%positive(4)
PLN 35.99
What games are like Mystery Island:Missing Amy?
The closest matches to Mystery Island:Missing Amy right now are Tiny Room Stories: Town Mystery, The Case of the Golden Idol, Elegant Sleuth:Mystic Family, Mystery Island：Enigmatic Painting, The Rise of the Golden Idol. The ranking compares 44 games by shared tags, theme and review quality, each with its cheapest price across official stores and keyshops.