Games like Papaya Plaza, ranked by tags and themes. Prices included.

1
Garden In!
86%positive
PLN 5.14
2
Puni the Florist
99%positive
PLN 42.49
3
Minami Lane
97%positive
PLN 4.27
4
STORY OF SEASONS: Grand Bazaar
94%positive
PLN 110.57
5
Dream Town Island
96%positive
PLN 55.49
6
Town to City
98%positive
PLN 74.52
7
My Time at Portia
92%positive
PLN 13.80
8
Townscaper
95%positive
PLN 5.83
9
Twinkleby
93%positive
PLN 11.57
10
Gourdlets
93%positive
PLN 2.94
11
Coral Island
89%positive
PLN 71.72
12
City Limits
100%positive
PLN 22.99
13
Lemon Cake
85%positive
PLN 14.94
14
Go-Go Town!
93%positive
PLN 71.25
15
The Greenening
97%positive
PLN 12.99
16
Echoes of the Plum Grove
88%positive
PLN 4.78
17
Mini City: Mayhem
88%positive
PLN 9.99
18
Sugardew Island - Your cozy farm shop
74%positive
PLN 9.07
19
Bunny Park
90%positive
PLN 3.45
20
Parkitect
94%positive
PLN 45.06
21
Cozy Grove
90%positive
PLN 67.99
22
Cozy Island
92%positive
PLN 30.74
23
Garden Paws
90%positive
PLN 37.09
24
Tiny Pasture
92%positive
PLN 7.94
25
Food Park Manager
82%positive
PLN 45.99
26
Roots of Pacha
94%positive
PLN 53.58
27
Dorfromantik
96%positive
PLN 33.14
28
Plantera
89%positive
PLN 3.35
29
Tropical Resort Story
90%positive
PLN 46.49
30
Tranquil Builds
100%positive
PLN 8.99
31
Bunhouse
94%positive
PLN 71.99
32
Mushroom Island
33
Little Corners
94%positive
PLN 21.54
34
Garden Life: A Cozy Simulator
76%positive
PLN 3.59
35
Pocket City
92%positive
PLN 13.49
36
Tropical Resort Simulator
84%positive
PLN 63.99
37
Verde
38
My Tiny Garden
70%positive
PLN 16.09
39
Critter Cove
95%positive
PLN 61.30
40
The Islander: Town Architect
76%positive
PLN 28.99
41
Dream House Days DX
84%positive
PLN 32.99
42
Small Spaces
89%positive
PLN 16.62
43
Cozy Nook
44
Pan'orama
89%positive
PLN 5.96
45
Tiny Terraces
93%positive
PLN 13.25
What games are like Papaya Plaza?

The closest matches to Papaya Plaza right now are Garden In!, Puni the Florist, Minami Lane, STORY OF SEASONS: Grand Bazaar, Dream Town Island. The ranking compares 45 games by shared tags, theme and review quality, each with its cheapest price across official stores and keyshops.