Games like Selma and the Wisp, ranked by tags and themes. Prices included.

1
Creepy Tale
86%positive
PLN 1.18
2
Beyond The Darkness
87%positive
PLN 45.99
3
ANIMAL WELL
96%positive
PLN 69.99
4
Semblance
86%positive
PLN 1.68
5
White Shadows
82%positive
PLN 5.23
6
Ayasa: Shadows of Silence
68%positive
PLN 42.66
7
The Thin Silence
81%positive
PLN 35.99
8
Alicemare
89%positive
PLN 4.39
9
Oscuro Blossom's Glow
94%positive
PLN 13.75
10
Ami
11
8874
12
Albert and Otto
64%positive
PLN 17.99
13
The Dreadful Whispers
84%positive
PLN 35.99
14
Whispering Willows
82%positive
PLN 3.15
15
Silence
84%positive
PLN 3.80
16
Inner silence
68%positive
PLN 2.24
17
TAMASHII
95%positive
PLN 22.99
18
Unspoken
100%positive
PLN 21.49
19
SILT
79%positive
PLN 4.67
20
Witch's Doll
86%positive
PLN 22.39
21
Creepy Tale: Snow Child
93%positive
PLN 50.99
22
Silent Descent
72%positive
PLN 6.40
23
Zemblanity
87%positive
PLN 17.99
24
ELMIA
73%positive
PLN 35.99
25
SELINI
94%positive
PLN 91.99
26
Memories of Fireflies
83%positive
PLN 17.99
27
The Midnight Walk
93%positive
PLN 62.99
28
Dark Places
56%positive
PLN 20.99
29
Pocket Witch
96%positive
PLN 8.99
30
Soulless: Ray Of Hope
73%positive
PLN 5.63
31
Silent Woods: the Cleansed
PLN 35.99
32
The Legend of Dark Witch
73%positive
PLN 17.14
33
Zelle
95%positive
PLN 45.12
34
The Silent Swan
70%positive
PLN 18.75
35
Witching Hour
68%positive
PLN 67.99
36
Wahm
100%positive
PLN 4.15
37
Living Shadows
100%positive
PLN 45.99
38
Dark Disharmony
59%positive
PLN 2.25
39
Dwalm
40
Selene's Unbearable Night
75%positive
PLN 54.99
41
Seduction
55%positive
PLN 28.99
42
Angel's Dreams
100%positive
PLN 7.49
43
Eldervale
88%positive
PLN 53.99
44
Seybul Tech
91%positive
PLN 4.49
45
Seductive Solitude
46
Ember Fall
67%positive
PLN 13.49
47
Fogrest: The Whisper of Harbingers
What games are like Selma and the Wisp?

The closest matches to Selma and the Wisp right now are Creepy Tale, Beyond The Darkness, ANIMAL WELL, Semblance, White Shadows. The ranking compares 47 games by shared tags, theme and review quality, each with its cheapest price across official stores and keyshops.